Comparative Analysis of Performance and Cost of Common Cable Trays
As the emphasis on electrical safety in industrial systems continues to grow, the role of cable trays within these systems has also gained increasing recognition. However, the current market offers a wide variety of cable tray products with varying quality and performance levels. To assist users in making informed choices and obtaining optimal solutions that balance performance and cost, this article provides a comparative analysis of the performance and pricing of cable trays made from different materials.
|
Metric |
Cable tray material (600×150×6000) |
|||||
|
Hot-dip Galvanized |
stainless steel |
Aluminum Alloy |
inorganic |
Composite Anti-corrosion |
||
|
Impact Strength |
2 |
12.5 |
||||
|
6-meter support load (kg/m) |
110 |
120 |
50 |
140 |
||
|
Maximum safe support distance (m) |
3 |
3 |
2 |
2 |
6 |
|
|
heat-resisting conduct |
thermal conductivity |
48.9 |
17.5 |
226 |
0.065 |
0.037 |
|
Surface heat absorption coefficient |
1.8 |
1.85 |
2.2 |
0.8 |
0.6 |
|
|
Flame retardant oxygen index (%): |
Non-flammable |
Non-flammable |
Non-flammable |
Non-flammable |
60 |
|
|
Fire-resistant rating of the fire protection cable tray |
Non-fire-resistant |
Non-fire-resistant |
Non-fire-resistant |
Non-fire-resistant |
F4 |
|
|
Shielding efficiency (dB) |
1 |
≥(40-60) |
||||
|
Acid-resistant (in 20% hydrochloric acid solution) |
Level 3 |
Level 5 |
Level 0 |
Level 9 |
Level 9 |
|
|
Alkali-resistant (40% sodium hydroxide) |
Level 0 |
Level 10 |
Level 0 |
Level 9 |
Level 9 |
|
|
Salt-resistant (salt spray test) |
Level 2 |
Level 9 |
Level 8 |
Level 10 |
Level 10 |
|
|
Weathering resistance (years) |
- |
1 |
3(600h) |
30(6000h) |
||
|
insulation function |
Surface Resistivity (Ω) |
0 |
0 |
0 |
3.51×10¹² |
|
|
Volume Resistivity (Ω) |
0 |
0 |
0 |
4.52×10" |
||
|
Protection Type (Highest Level) |
W |
WF1 |
F1 |
F1 |
WF2 |
|
Note: 1. The aforementioned data is accompanied by relevant test reports;
2. The ultimate load data exceeds the national standard (for a 6-meter support).Self-test data obtained;
3. The inorganic cable tray is an uncommon type, and the data are incomplete.
In conclusion:
1. Inorganic material cable trays are unsuitable for outdoor applications (they tend to powder upon contact with water) and are even less appropriate as fire-resistant (fireproof) cable trays (though they may not be entirely non-fire-resistant); additionally, their load-bearing capacity is poor.
2. Aluminum alloy cable trays are not suitable for use as cable trays. They exhibit poor resistance to acid and alkali corrosion; their high thermal absorption coefficient and thermal conductivity significantly reduce the service life of cables and increase the uncertainty of system safety; they possess poor load-bearing capacity; and involve high investment costs and production expenses.
3. Stainless steel cable trays have limited application scenarios. They are not resistant to chloride ion corrosion; moreover, they require high initial investment and incur elevated operating costs.
4. Heat-invasion zinc cable trays are only suitable for non-corrosive environments, offering poor corrosion resistance and employing environmentally unfriendly manufacturing processes.
5. The composite anti-corrosion cable tray is a versatile, high-performance cable tray suitable for all applications and fields, offering excellent cost-effectiveness. It features high strength, strong corrosion resistance, thermal insulation, flame retardancy, fire resistance (fireproof), shielding, and insulation properties. Its manufacturing and installation processes are highly environmentally friendly, with convenient installation, an aesthetically pleasing appearance, and low investment costs, making it the optimal choice for cable tray materials.
The above explanation is subject to the discretion of: R&D Center, Hebei Fuent Electric Equipment Group Co., Ltd
